PesWiki.com

Menu

Talk:Directory:Bell Bio-Energy, Inc

Lasted edited by Andrew Munsey, updated on June 14, 2016 at 10:00 pm.

  • This page has been imported from the old peswiki website. This message will be removed once updated.

Discussion page for Directory:Bell Bio-Energy, Inc

Comments

Long way as yet

On May 7, 2008, New Energy Congress member, Congress:Member:Mark Snoswell wrote:

This announcement is a long, long way from anything [practical] as yet. Not a Congress:Top 100 Technologies -- RD candidate at present....

The problem is not getting bacteria to grow on anything -- or to produce

just about any hydrocarbon. The problem is engineering a process that

produces combustible fuel (alcohol's primarily) in commercial quantities and

at viable costs... also without generating significant waste in the process.

Way back when I did my PhD I was working with recombinant E.coli that produced growth hormone. Making the recombinant bacteria was the easy part. Purifying a product from them is not so easy.

Would Be Better to Just Produce Methane

On May 12, 2008, New Energy Congress member, Congress:Member:Mark Snoswell wrote:

One of the big problems is that the product you are making is toxic in higher concentrations... even more so than ethanol. So you will only get a low volume yield of product for a large amount of biomass – which is a waste product in its own right. Unlike yeas waste bacterial waste is not as amenable to recycling.

And before anyone suggests a continuous fermentation process – there are massive (costly) problems in maintain a continuous process. It also generate a lot more waste water in the process and de-watering is one of the most expensive things in a downstream process.

Apart from all of this I suspect their process may not work due the problem of the long chain alcohols disrupting the cell membranes. Ethanol is only barely OK, butanol really not so good... by the time you get to octanol there are serious toxicity problems due to cell wall disruption. Octane is even worse.

So – while I would love something like this to be viable I have serious doubts that it ever will. To be honest -- they would be far better of engineering the bugs for methane production – so much easier to design a continuous and low cost process harvesting a gas.

Comments